This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Consultations available here via appointments 📆

Lab Grown vs Natural Diamonds: An Honest Comparison

If you're shopping for an engagement ring today, one of the first decisions you'll face is whether to choose a lab grown diamond or a natural (mined) diamond. Both are real diamonds, and both can be absolutely stunning. The differences come down to origin, price, and what matters most to you. Here's a clear, honest comparison to help you decide.

Are lab grown diamonds real diamonds?

Yes. Lab grown diamonds are chemically, physically and optically the same as diamonds formed in the earth: pure carbon arranged in the same crystal structure, with the same hardness (10 on the Mohs scale), the same brilliance and the same fire. They are not simulants like cubic zirconia or moissanite. To the naked eye, and even under a jeweler's loupe, a lab grown diamond and a natural diamond of the same quality look identical. Telling them apart takes specialized lab equipment.

The only real difference is where the diamond formed. A natural diamond formed deep underground over a very long time and was mined. A lab grown diamond is grown in a controlled environment using advanced technology that recreates the conditions in which diamonds form. After that, both are cut, polished and graded the same way.

Lab grown vs natural diamonds at a glance

Lab grown diamond Natural diamond
Material Real diamond (carbon) Real diamond (carbon)
Hardness 10 (Mohs) 10 (Mohs)
Look and sparkle Identical at the same cut, color and clarity Identical at the same cut, color and clarity
Origin Grown in a lab Formed in the earth and mined
Price Typically much lower for the same size and quality Typically much higher
Grading Graded and certified by gem labs such as IGI Graded and certified by gem labs such as GIA and IGI
Resale value Generally low Higher, but usually well below the retail price paid

The biggest difference: price

For most couples, price is what tips the decision. Because lab grown diamonds don't depend on mining, they typically cost far less than natural diamonds of the same carat, color, clarity and cut. In practice, that means you can often choose a larger center stone, a higher color or clarity grade, or put more of your budget toward the setting you love, without changing the overall look of the diamond.

What about resale value?

It's worth being honest here: if resale value is important to you, natural diamonds generally hold more of their value than lab grown diamonds. That said, very few people buy an engagement ring planning to sell it, and even natural diamonds usually resell for well below what was paid at retail. Most couples choose an engagement ring to wear and love for a lifetime, which is why the upfront price and the beauty of the ring tend to matter more than resale.

Sourcing and peace of mind

Many of our clients choose lab grown diamonds because they come from a known, traceable source and don't require new mining. For us at Everelle, that peace of mind is a big part of why we work with lab grown diamonds. Our family has been in the jewelry business for over 40 years, and lab grown diamonds let us carry on that heritage while staying true to our values.

How to tell if a diamond is lab grown

You can't tell by looking. Reputable sellers will always disclose whether a diamond is lab grown or natural, and certified lab grown diamonds come with a grading report that states the diamond's origin. Many certified lab grown diamonds also carry a microscopic laser inscription on the girdle that matches the report. When you shop, ask for the grading report and make sure it lists the diamond as laboratory-grown.

Want to understand what's on a grading report? Read our guide to understanding diamond certification for engagement rings.

How to choose a lab grown diamond

Shopping for a lab grown diamond works just like shopping for a natural one. Focus on:

  • Cut: The quality of the cut has the biggest effect on sparkle. A well-cut diamond looks brighter and livelier.
  • Color: Near-colorless grades look bright white in most settings, especially white gold and platinum.
  • Clarity: Look for an "eye-clean" stone, meaning you can't see any inclusions without magnification.
  • Carat and shape: Choose the shape that fits your style, from classic round and oval to emerald, radiant, pear and marquise. See our guide to diamond cuts and shapes.
  • Certification: For larger center stones, choose a certified diamond with a grading report from an independent lab.

Lab grown diamond vs moissanite

Lab grown diamonds are sometimes confused with moissanite, but they're different gemstones. Moissanite is silicon carbide, not diamond, and has a hardness of 9.25 and more colorful fire. If you're weighing those two options, read our comparison of moissanite vs lab diamonds.

So, which should you choose?

Choose a natural diamond if having a stone formed in the earth is meaningful to you, or if resale value is a priority. Choose a lab grown diamond if you want the same beauty and durability with more value for your budget and a traceable, mining-free origin. There's no wrong answer, only the right ring for you.

Shop lab grown diamond engagement rings at Everelle

Every Everelle engagement ring is crafted in solid 14k or 18k gold or platinum, and our larger lab grown center stones come with a grading report from an independent gem lab. Browse our lab grown diamond engagement rings, or work with us to design a custom engagement ring around the exact diamond you want. All US orders ship free and insured, and you're welcome to book an appointment to see our pieces in person.